European Origin of Sanskrit Language

80

By jainismus

Sanskrit is Alien to India

Sanskrit Pundits and Sanskrit lovers like to find similarities in words of European languages and that of Sanskrit. This way they are supporting the theory that Sanskrit has its roots in Europe.

There are many words in Sanskrit which are similar to Latin, Russian, Greek, English and other European language. We can find Similarities in pronunciation and similarity in meanings. One of the great examples is the Word 'Maatru' for Mother in English, Mater in Latin, Mere in French, Mutter in German and Madre in Spanish.On the other hand the Sanskrit word for Father is Pitru/ Pitar. The European equivalents for this word are Pater in Latin, Father in English, Padre in Spanish, Vater (pronounced Fater) in German. These two words are the basic and ancient words as the child learns it as his first and second word to speak and they are being used for thousands of years.

Now if you see what words are used for Matru and Pitru in Indian languages, you will be surprised to know that there are no sound similarities in the words with these Sanskrit words.

Here is the list of words for Matru in major Hindian langauges: Tamil: Amma, Kannada: Aau, Marathi: Aai, Gujarati: Baa, Rajasthani: Baai, Urdu: Ammi, Magadhi: Amba etc. In Hindi the word for mother is Maa, but as this language is most Sanskritized language, we should find the original equivalent which is Amba.

The equivalent words for Pitru in Indian languages are:Bapp in Magadhi. Aappa in Tamil, Baap in Hindi, Aappa/ Baapa in Kannada, Baaba in Marathi, Baapu in Gujarati and Abba/ Baba in Urdu.

Thus we find that there are no similarities between Sanskrit and other Indian languages in these two most important words. At the same time we find similarities between Sanskrit and European languages in case of these two words.

There are lot of other words in Sanskrit which have similarities with the words of European languages.

Other Similarities

1. A great similarity between Sanskrit and some European languages is the use of Dual Number. In Sanskrit, it is called as Dvi Vachan. In ancient Latin and Greek languages dual numbers were used and languages of Slavic group till use this form. But no Indian language use this form.

2. In Sanskrit language, there is a high number of compound letters having letter R in it. i.e. BRahmin, Kram, KaRM, NaMR, AyuRVed, KRut, KRiya, KRipa, rashTRa and so on. In European languages also we see high number of compound letters having letter R in it. But on other hand, you will not find compound letters having R in it in original words of Indian languages.

3. Further, there are lot of words with compound letters DRa and TRa. like InDRa, miTRa, shaTRu, TRi, PuTR, shuDRa etc. Such compound letters are also found in Russian language. In Russian language TSa is a compound letter, we find it in Sanskrit also. But in Indian languages you will not find such compound letters in original words.

4. One of the distinctive feature in compound letters in Indian languages is that there are lot of words having compound letters containing same letter for two times, or having letters of same group i.e. Buddha, Khatta, Dilli, Mudda, Chhutta, Abba, Ammi etc. Sanskrit and European languages lack of such compound words.

5. DV is another common compound letter found in Russian and Sanskrit languages.

All these facts clearly indicate that Sanskrit is closer to European languages, not to Indian languages. Why it is so? The answer is easy. Sanskirt was language of the Aryans who came to India from Eastern parts of Europe. There language was the same which was spoken in that part of world. When they came to India, it was changed due to the influence of indigenous languages of India.

-Mahavir Sanglikar

Comments

uday 7 months ago

I HAVE SEEN A PROGRAM ON DISCOVERY STATING

IN THE BEGINNING THERE WERE ONLY TEN MONTHS IN A YEAR

7(SAPTA)=SEPTEMBER

8(ASHTA)=OCTOER

9(NAVAM)=NOVEMBER

10(DASHAM)=DECEMBER

Dhira Simha 6 months ago

You can find a lot more words at this site where parts of the new "Russian-Sanskrit Dictionary of Common and Cognate Words" are being published:

borissoff.wordpress.com/current-project/

chakravarthiamith 5 months ago

Aryans spoke Indo iranian language(Old persian not existant today) which was an offshot of Indo europian language. when they reached india some polishing happened to it giving raise to Vedic sanskrit. Yes root is from persia, but first true sanskrit was born in india. please check the geniology and world language family. i am working on it for last 40years. i can authoritatively say what i say is pritty much exact.

jainismus profile image

jainismus Hub Author 3 months ago

chakravarthiamith,

You are right when you say that Sanskrit was born into India, but but the roots of the language are surely European.

TusharKapila 8 weeks ago

agree with jainismus sort of :- Sanskrit was born into India, but some words of the language are surely European. just as some words in English are from Hindi and others from other World languages. Thank God for no copy right on words!

am sure some words were common but i think sanskrit is bigger than those similarities. and a lot of other words in other Indian langs (besides tamil which i think developed in a seperate branch) borrowed words from sanskrit - which came before them.

but i think the important thing to consider is that before does not mean better ... we have many languages in the world - actively spoken and they should all be given respect and i hope atleast a few people keep using them to keep them alive.

what i would like (and is happending because of economic and increased travel, commerce, media) is a common language - English as its the most spoken in India and other place around the world.

Its super frustrating to communicate simple ideas - try to explain to a taxi chap where your house is or ask someone where a tourist spot is and u cant just cause u dont have a common language. wasting time, money, petrol for nothing; and on the other end of spectrum the few who do know a bridge language cheat others (have seen in folks in Bangalore when they want to sell land AND heard about villagers when they sell produce via middle men / translaters). /end of grumbling :)

Dhira Simha 8 weeks ago

TusharKapila, the issue is not that some words of the language are surely European. It is only one side of it. The deeper genetic unity is in the very structure of the language. Take Russian, for example, it still preserves most of the Vedic grammar. Nouns, adjectives, pronouns, numerals are all fully declinable in 6 cases. Not a single living Indo-Aryan language preserves this. Parts of sentences are still mutiually comprehensible (after at least 5 thousand years!). If you know Sanskrit you will have no problem understanding this russian text (in phonetic transcription as it souns): Eta noviy dom. V etam dome jivet mate? sa svaimi trimya sinami...

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working